Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)
  • Local News
    • Balerno News
    • Bruntsfield News
    • Calton Hill News
    • Colinton News
    • Corstorphine News
    • Currie News
    • Dean Village News
    • Duddingston News
    • Edinburgh Council News
    • Grassmarket News
  • Crime News
    • Balerno Crime News
    • Bruntsfield Crime News
    • Calton Hill Crime News
    • Colinton Crime News
    • Corstorphine Crime News
    • Currie Crime News
    • Leith Crime News
    • Kirkliston Crime News
    • Juniper Green Crime News
    • Grassmarket Crime News
  • Police News
    • Balerno Police News
    • Bruntsfield Police News
    • Calton Hill Police News
    • Colinton Police News
    • Corstorphine Police News
    • Currie Police News
    • Dean Village Police News
    • Duddingston Police News
    • Grassmarket Police News
    • Juniper Green Police News
    • Kirkliston Police News
  • Fire News
    • Balerno Fire News
    • Bruntsfield Fire News
    • Calton Hill Fire News
    • Colinton Fire News
    • Corstorphine Fire News
    • Currie Fire News
    • Dean Village Fire News
    • Duddingston Fire News
    • Grassmarket Fire News
    • Juniper Green Fire News
    • Kirkliston Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Edinburgh Rugby
    • Edinburgh University A.F.C.
    • Heart of Midlothian F.C.
    • Hibernian F.C.
    • Leith Athletic F.C.
    • Edinburgh City F.C.
    • Edinburgh Eagles
Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)
  • Local News
    • Balerno News
    • Bruntsfield News
    • Calton Hill News
    • Colinton News
    • Corstorphine News
    • Currie News
    • Dean Village News
    • Duddingston News
    • Edinburgh Council News
    • Grassmarket News
  • Crime News
    • Balerno Crime News
    • Bruntsfield Crime News
    • Calton Hill Crime News
    • Colinton Crime News
    • Corstorphine Crime News
    • Currie Crime News
    • Leith Crime News
    • Kirkliston Crime News
    • Juniper Green Crime News
    • Grassmarket Crime News
  • Police News
    • Balerno Police News
    • Bruntsfield Police News
    • Calton Hill Police News
    • Colinton Police News
    • Corstorphine Police News
    • Currie Police News
    • Dean Village Police News
    • Duddingston Police News
    • Grassmarket Police News
    • Juniper Green Police News
    • Kirkliston Police News
  • Fire News
    • Balerno Fire News
    • Bruntsfield Fire News
    • Calton Hill Fire News
    • Colinton Fire News
    • Corstorphine Fire News
    • Currie Fire News
    • Dean Village Fire News
    • Duddingston Fire News
    • Grassmarket Fire News
    • Juniper Green Fire News
    • Kirkliston Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Edinburgh Rugby
    • Edinburgh University A.F.C.
    • Heart of Midlothian F.C.
    • Hibernian F.C.
    • Leith Athletic F.C.
    • Edinburgh City F.C.
    • Edinburgh Eagles
Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) > Local Edinburgh News​ > No exceptional circumstances for private prosecution of Goodwillie, Edinburgh 2026
Local Edinburgh News​

No exceptional circumstances for private prosecution of Goodwillie, Edinburgh 2026

News Desk
Last updated: November 12, 2026 3:16 pm
News Desk
1 week ago
Newsroom Staff -
@Edinburgh_Daily
Share
Credit: Google maps, PA

Key Points

  • Crown lawyer Alan Cameron KC told the Criminal Appeal Court in Edinburgh that no exceptional circumstances exist to allow a private prosecution of former Scotland footballer David Goodwillie.
  • Denise Clair is applying for a Bill of Criminal Letters to privately prosecute Goodwillie, after a civil court ruled in 2017 that Goodwillie and his former teammate David Robertson raped her in 2011.
  • Clair’s lawyer, Thomas Ross KC, said the Crown Office made an “irrational” decision in 2011 by not prosecuting Goodwillie, arguing there had been a reasonable prospect of conviction.
  • Advocate Juliette Casey, who also represents Clair, asked the three judges to grant the application almost 16 years after the incident and nearly 10 years after the civil ruling.
  • In June 2026, the Crown Office admitted an “error of judgment” in 2011, stating there had been enough circumstantial evidence in law to show Clair lacked the capacity to consent.
  • Goodwillie, who maintains his innocence, is represented by Lord Stewart of Dirleton KC before judges Lord Pentland, Lord Matthews, and Lady Carmichael.

Edinburgh (Edinburgh Daily) November 12, 2026 – A senior Crown lawyer has told the Criminal Appeal Court in Edinburgh that there are “no exceptional circumstances” to permit a rare bid to privately prosecute former Scotland footballer David Goodwillie over a 2011 rape allegation.

Contents
  • Key Points
  • Why is Denise Clair seeking a private prosecution against David Goodwillie?
  • What arguments were presented by Denise Clair’s legal team?
  • How did the Crown Office respond to the private prosecution bid?
  • What is David Goodwillie’s position in the court proceedings?
  • What is the background to the David Goodwillie legal case?
  • How could this ruling affect complainants and the Scottish justice system?

During a hearing on Thursday before Lord Pentland, Lord Matthews, and Lady Carmichael, Alan Cameron KC argued on behalf of the Crown that prosecutors had acted correctly when they decided not to bring criminal charges against Mr Goodwillie.

The legal bid has been brought by Denise Clair, who won a landmark civil court ruling in 2017 in which a judge found that Mr Goodwillie and his former Dundee United teammate David Robertson had raped her in January 2011.

Why is Denise Clair seeking a private prosecution against David Goodwillie?

Ms Clair is applying for a Bill of Criminal Letters, an exceedingly rare legal mechanism in Scotland that allows a private individual to prosecute a criminal case when the Crown Office has declined to do so.

As reported by Lucinda Cameron of The Independent, advocate Juliette Casey, acting alongside Thomas Ross KC for Ms Clair, urged the three appeal judges to allow the private prosecution to proceed.

As reported by Lucinda Cameron of The Independent, Ms Casey stated: “I urge the court, almost 16 years after the allegation of rape and almost 10 years after the civil case to grant this Bill of Criminal letters.”

To succeed in bringing a private prosecution in Scotland, Ms Clair’s legal team must satisfy a stringent legal test by proving that the Lord Advocate made a decision that no reasonable prosecutor could have reached.

What arguments were presented by Denise Clair’s legal team?

Addressing the court on Thursday, Mr Ross contended that the Crown Office had reached an “irrational” decision when it opted not to prosecute Mr Goodwillie following the 2011 police investigation.

Mr Ross told the bench that he believed there was a reasonable prospect of conviction at the time, arguing that evidence from a neighbour heard during Ms Clair’s subsequent civil action had been “confused”.

Earlier in the proceedings, as reported by Marion Scott of The Sunday Post in June 2026, the Crown Office had formally admitted an “error of judgment” regarding the 2011 case, acknowledging that there had been prima facie sufficient circumstantial evidence in law to establish that Ms Clair lacked the capacity to consent.

How did the Crown Office respond to the private prosecution bid?

Responding to Mr Ross’s submissions, Crown counsel Alan Cameron KC maintained that the prospect of conviction would have been properly assessed by the Crown in 2011.

Mr Cameron submitted that when all the available evidence in the case was taken into account, the Crown was fully entitled not to bring Mr Goodwillie to a criminal trial.

As reported by The Courier, Mr Cameron stated: “There are no exceptional circumstances which would permit the issuing of criminal letters.”

In written submissions to the court, Mr Cameron further argued that the decision not to prosecute “did not involve an egregious error on the Lord Advocate’s part”, noting that a mere error of judgment is legally insufficient to meet the high threshold of exceptionality required for a private prosecution.

What is David Goodwillie’s position in the court proceedings?

Mr Goodwillie, a former striker for Dundee United, Blackburn Rovers, Aberdeen, and Plymouth Argyle, has consistently insisted that he is innocent.

He has previously stated on a podcast that he wished to move on with his life, and his legal team has previously clarified to the court that he opposes being subjected to a criminal prosecution.

Following the submissions from the Crown, Mr Goodwillie’s counsel, Lord Stewart of Dirleton KC, is scheduled to address the Criminal Appeal Court on his client’s behalf as the hearing continues.

What is the background to the David Goodwillie legal case?

The legal battle stems from events in the early hours of January 2, 2011, when Ms Clair was taken to a flat in Armadale, West Lothian, by Mr Goodwillie and Mr Robertson following a night out.

In July 2011, the Crown Office dropped criminal charges against Mr Goodwillie due to what it then described as insufficient evidence, while Mr Robertson was never charged.

In 2017, after waiving her right to anonymity, Ms Clair pursued a historic civil action at the Court of Session in Edinburgh—the first civil rape case in Scotland since 1926.

Judge Lord Armstrong ruled on the balance of probabilities that both footballers had taken advantage of Ms Clair when she was incapable of giving meaningful consent due to excessive alcohol consumption, ordering them to pay £100,000 in damages.

An appeal by Mr Goodwillie against the civil ruling was later rejected, and in 2022 Ms Clair formally initiated the process to seek a private criminal prosecution after obtaining disclosed Crown documents.

How could this ruling affect complainants and the Scottish justice system?

The outcome of this hearing carries significant implications for sexual offence complainants, legal practitioners, and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service in Scotland.

Private prosecutions are exceptionally rare in Scottish legal history, with only two granted in the 20th century and none thus far in the 21st century.

If the bench of three judges refuses Ms Clair’s Bill of Criminal Letters, it will reinforce the high legal barrier protecting the Lord Advocate’s prosecutorial discretion, establishing that even an admitted “error of judgment” by the Crown does not automatically open the door for private citizens to bring criminal trials.

Conversely, if the Criminal Appeal Court grants the application, it would mark a historic legal precedent in modern Scots law, potentially encouraging other complainants whose cases were dropped by public prosecutors to seek alternative criminal recourse through private bills.

Edinburgh Landlords Relaunch Neidpath Inn in Peebles Borders 2026
New Coach Service to Link Edinburgh City Centre with Glasgow Airport 2026
Edinburgh easyJet Flight Diverts After Mid-Air Emergency
The Black Bull Remains Edinburgh Rugby’s Home Away From Hive 2026
Archdiocese Sells Historic Edinburgh Site 2026
News Desk
ByNews Desk
Follow:
Independent voice of Edinburgh, delivering timely news, local insights, politics, business, and community stories with accuracy and impact.
Previous Article Cockenzie House Gains Approval for Year-Round Events in East Lothian 2026
Next Article Morrisons Launches Flashing Shelf Labels in 270 Stores UK 2026

All the day’s headlines and highlights from Edinburgh Daily News (EDN), direct to you every morning.

Area We Cover

  • Balerno News
  • Bruntsfield News
  • Calton Hill News
  • Colinton News
  • Corstorphine News
  • Currie News
  • Dean Village News

Explore News

  • Crime News
  • Stabbing News
  • Fire News
  • Live Traffic & Travel News
  • Police News
  • Sports News

Discover EDN

  • About Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)
  • Become EDN Reporter
  • Contact Us
  • Street Journalism Training Programme (Online Course)

Useful Links

  • Contact Us
  • Cookies Policy
  • Code of Ethics
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap

Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) is the part of Times Intelligence Media Group. Visit timesintelligence.com website to get to know the full list of our news publications

Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?