Key Points
- Former Strictly Come Dancing professional Brendan Cole addressed the backlash over his criticism of current professional dancer Amy Dowden.
- Cole said his earlier remarks about Dowden not being “up to the challenge” were focused on dance performance and competition standards.
- Dowden’s past breast cancer treatment did not factor into his critique, according to Cole, who said all competitors should be judged equally.
- Cole called Dowden a “lovely girl” and a “beautiful dancer,” and admitted his own routines fell short during some weeks of his 15-series run.
- Dowden had earlier described Cole’s comments as “upsetting,” urged people to “be kind,” and said she did not want to give him attention.
London (Edinburgh Daily) November 14, 2026 – Former Strictly Come Dancing professional Brendan Cole has publicly addressed the backlash surrounding his critical remarks about fellow dancer Amy Dowden, insisting his comments were strictly focused on competition standards rather than personal matters.
- Key Points
- What did Brendan Cole say about his criticism of Amy Dowden?
- What sparked the dispute between Brendan Cole and Amy Dowden?
- How did Amy Dowden and other Strictly stars respond?
- Background of Amy Dowden’s Strictly Come Dancing journey
- How could this development affect Strictly Come Dancing viewers and professionals?
Speaking during a recent interview, the 50-year-old dancer sought to clarify his position after facing criticism from viewers and former colleagues over his assessment of Dowden’s recent performances on the BBC One programme.
What did Brendan Cole say about his criticism of Amy Dowden?
As reported by Edinburgh Live, Cole maintained that his critique of Dowden’s choreography and teaching was purely professional and did not take her medical history into account. When asked by interviewer Jeremy whether Dowden’s breast cancer journey had crossed his mind before making his initial comments, Cole explained that he views all participants through a competitive lens.
As reported by Edinburgh Live, Cole stated: “If I’m critiquing somebody that’s got one leg, I don’t go ‘I’m going to have to go lenient on them because they’ve got one leg’. If you’re in a competition, you’re in a competition.”
Cole further emphasised that he holds no personal animosity toward the Welsh dancer, praising her character and natural ability while standing by his assessment of her recent series.
As reported by Edinburgh Live, Cole continued: “To go on the record, I love Amy, I think she’s a lovely girl, she’s a beautiful dancer, I didn’t think she did a particularly good job on the show this year. That was my point. I didn’t think about the fact she had survived cancer.”
Reflecting on his own extensive history on the BBC ballroom programme, Cole acknowledged that inconsistency is a normal part of the show’s demanding schedule. He noted that he performed between 150 and 200 routines across 15 series and admitted that not every dance met the highest standard, adding that there were weeks where he let both himself and his celebrity partners down.
What sparked the dispute between Brendan Cole and Amy Dowden?
The controversy began earlier in the autumn following Dowden’s early elimination from the 2026 series of Strictly Come Dancing alongside her celebrity partner, hairstylist Chris Appleton. Following their exit, Cole gave an interview in which he questioned Dowden’s recent track record on the programme.
As reported by Holly Bishop of The Standard, Cole previously remarked: “Amy has not been up to the challenge, in my opinion. I don’t think Amy’s been doing a very good job for the last few years and she’s been out first for the last few years. One can do the maths on that.”
During those earlier remarks, Cole also claimed he could see Dowden “counting in” her celebrity partners during live broadcasts, which he suggested was a sign that the teaching job had not been completed properly and that audiences were not enjoying the routines.
How did Amy Dowden and other Strictly stars respond?
Dowden addressed Cole’s original remarks during several media appearances in October, describing the critique as “upsetting” while emphasising the importance of kindness and serving as a positive role model.
As reported by The Mirror, Dowden stated: “I’ll be honest, what do you expect from him? It’s fine. I’ve never been brought up to be personal, and in this day and age especially I think it’s so important to be kind, and to think about the next generation.”
Speaking on the red carpet at the Pride of Britain awards, Dowden added that Cole had her telephone number and could have contacted her directly rather than worrying about press headlines. As reported by HuffPost UK, Dowden told reporters: “I don’t know, I just don’t want to give him the attention he so desperately craves.”
Dowden also posted a video on Instagram lip-syncing to Mariah Carey’s song Obsessed with hashtags promoting kindness, which drew supportive comments from fellow Strictly professionals including Aljaž Škorjanec, Dianne Buswell, Kevin Clifton, and Carlos Gu.
Meanwhile, former Strictly professional James Jordan defended Cole’s intentions. As reported by Meghna Amin of Express.co.uk, Jordan told Mail Online that Cole was “gutted” by the public reaction and insisted his friend’s comments about choreography had been “blown all out of proportion.”
Background of Amy Dowden’s Strictly Come Dancing journey
Amy Dowden joined the professional line-up of Strictly Come Dancing in 2017 and quickly became a prominent figure on the BBC One flagship show. Her recent years on the series have been marked by significant personal and physical challenges.
In May 2023, Dowden was diagnosed with breast cancer, which forced her to step away from competing with a celebrity partner during the 2023 series while she underwent chemotherapy and treatment. In February 2024, she announced that tests showed “no evidence of disease,” allowing her to return to the competition later that year.
Her 2024 comeback alongside JLS singer JB Gill was cut short mid-series after Dowden sustained a foot injury, resulting in fellow professional Lauren Oakley stepping in to complete the season with Gill. Dowden returned for the 2025 series with partner Thomas Skinner, where the pair were the first couple eliminated following a dance-off. Her early departure with Chris Appleton in October 2026 marked her second consecutive first-week elimination.
How could this development affect Strictly Come Dancing viewers and professionals?
Cole’s latest clarification is likely to keep public debate focused on how former cast members and media commentators critique current Strictly Come Dancing professionals. For television audiences, the exchange highlights a recurring divide between viewers who expect blunt, technical assessments of ballroom choreography and fans who favour supportive commentary, particularly regarding dancers who have overcome major health setbacks.
For current Strictly professionals, the ongoing scrutiny underscores the intense pressure surrounding early eliminations and choreography standards. While Cole’s attempt to downplay the controversy as “not a big deal” may close the immediate chapter on his feud with Dowden, former dancers remain active voices in British entertainment media, meaning on-air performances will continue to face candid post-show analysis.
