Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)
  • Local News
    • Balerno News
    • Bruntsfield News
    • Calton Hill News
    • Colinton News
    • Corstorphine News
    • Currie News
    • Dean Village News
    • Duddingston News
    • Edinburgh Council News
    • Grassmarket News
  • Crime News
    • Balerno Crime News
    • Bruntsfield Crime News
    • Calton Hill Crime News
    • Colinton Crime News
    • Corstorphine Crime News
    • Currie Crime News
    • Leith Crime News
    • Kirkliston Crime News
    • Juniper Green Crime News
    • Grassmarket Crime News
  • Police News
    • Balerno Police News
    • Bruntsfield Police News
    • Calton Hill Police News
    • Colinton Police News
    • Corstorphine Police News
    • Currie Police News
    • Dean Village Police News
    • Duddingston Police News
    • Grassmarket Police News
    • Juniper Green Police News
    • Kirkliston Police News
  • Fire News
    • Balerno Fire News
    • Bruntsfield Fire News
    • Calton Hill Fire News
    • Colinton Fire News
    • Corstorphine Fire News
    • Currie Fire News
    • Dean Village Fire News
    • Duddingston Fire News
    • Grassmarket Fire News
    • Juniper Green Fire News
    • Kirkliston Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Edinburgh Rugby
    • Edinburgh University A.F.C.
    • Heart of Midlothian F.C.
    • Hibernian F.C.
    • Leith Athletic F.C.
    • Edinburgh City F.C.
    • Edinburgh Eagles
Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)
  • Local News
    • Balerno News
    • Bruntsfield News
    • Calton Hill News
    • Colinton News
    • Corstorphine News
    • Currie News
    • Dean Village News
    • Duddingston News
    • Edinburgh Council News
    • Grassmarket News
  • Crime News
    • Balerno Crime News
    • Bruntsfield Crime News
    • Calton Hill Crime News
    • Colinton Crime News
    • Corstorphine Crime News
    • Currie Crime News
    • Leith Crime News
    • Kirkliston Crime News
    • Juniper Green Crime News
    • Grassmarket Crime News
  • Police News
    • Balerno Police News
    • Bruntsfield Police News
    • Calton Hill Police News
    • Colinton Police News
    • Corstorphine Police News
    • Currie Police News
    • Dean Village Police News
    • Duddingston Police News
    • Grassmarket Police News
    • Juniper Green Police News
    • Kirkliston Police News
  • Fire News
    • Balerno Fire News
    • Bruntsfield Fire News
    • Calton Hill Fire News
    • Colinton Fire News
    • Corstorphine Fire News
    • Currie Fire News
    • Dean Village Fire News
    • Duddingston Fire News
    • Grassmarket Fire News
    • Juniper Green Fire News
    • Kirkliston Fire News
  • Sports News
    • Edinburgh Rugby
    • Edinburgh University A.F.C.
    • Heart of Midlothian F.C.
    • Hibernian F.C.
    • Leith Athletic F.C.
    • Edinburgh City F.C.
    • Edinburgh Eagles
Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) > Area Guide > Burke and Hare Murders and 19th Century Medicine History
Area Guide

Burke and Hare Murders and 19th Century Medicine History

News Desk
Last updated: November 16, 2026 12:03 pm
News Desk
4 days ago
Newsroom Staff -
@Edinburgh_Daily
Share
Credit: google maps

The Burke and Hare murders were a series of sixteen homicides committed in Edinburgh, Scotland, between November 1827 and October 1828. Irish immigrants William Burke and William Hare suffocated victims and sold the corpses to Dr. Robert Knox for anatomical dissection.

Contents
  • What Were the Burke and Hare Murders?
  • Why Did 19th-Century Medicine Rely on Illegal Cadavers?
  • Who Was Dr. Robert Knox and What Was His Role?
  • How Were Burke and Hare Caught and Prosecuted?
  • What Happened After the Trial of William Burke?
  • How Did the Anatomy Act 1832 Reform Medical Science?
        • Why didn’t Dr. Robert Knox go to prison for buying bodies from Burke and Hare?
        • What happened to William Hare after he testified against William Burke?
        • What is the difference between burking and grave robbing?
        • Is William Burke’s skeleton still on display in Edinburgh?
        • How many people did Burke and Hare actually kill?

These crimes exposed a severe legal shortage of cadavers for medical education, directly triggering the passage of the Anatomy Act 1832 in the United Kingdom.

Edinburgh functioned as the premier center for anatomical study in Europe during the early nineteenth century. Medical students traveled from across the British Empire to attend lectures at the University of Edinburgh and private extramural schools. However, British law strictly limited the legal supply of human bodies to executed criminals under the Murder Act 1752.

Because execution rates declined sharply in the early 1800s, the legal supply of corpses dropped to fewer than fifty per year across Britain. Simultaneously, the number of enrolled medical students in Edinburgh expanded to over nine hundred annually. This extreme imbalance created a lucrative black market for human remains, driving anatomists to purchase bodies without questioning their origins.

What Were the Burke and Hare Murders?

Credit: google maps

The Burke and Hare murders were sixteen calculated killings in Edinburgh, Scotland, executed over ten months in 1827 and 1828. William Burke and William Hare murdered vulnerable lodgers and street dwellers, selling each fresh corpse to anatomist Robert Knox for cash.

William Burke and William Hare originated from Ulster, Ireland, and worked as laborers on the Union Canal before settling in Edinburgh’s West Port district. Hare operated Tanner’s Close, a cheap lodging house managed alongside his partner, Margaret Logue. Burke lived in the same tenement with his companion, Helen McDougal.

The criminal enterprise began accidentally in November 1827 when an elderly pensioner named Donald died of natural causes in Hare’s lodging house owing four pounds in rent. To recover the unpaid debt, Burke and Hare filled Donald’s coffin with tanner’s bark and sold his body at Surgeons’ Square for seven pounds and ten shillings. Realizing the high profitability of fresh cadavers, the pair transitioned from opportunistic sales to deliberate murder.

Instead of exhuming buried corpses, Burke and Hare lured impoverished, elderly, or transient individuals into Tanner’s Close. They plied their victims with whiskey until the targets lost consciousness. Hare then pressed his hands over the victim’s nose and mouth while Burke lay across the chest to restrict breathing, a suffocation method later termed burking.

Why Did 19th-Century Medicine Rely on Illegal Cadavers?

Nineteenth-century medicine relied on illegal cadavers because British statutory law restricted legal dissections exclusively to executed murderers. Rapidly growing medical schools required hundreds of bodies annually for surgical training, forcing anatomists to purchase corpses from body snatchers and murderers.

Modernizing surgical practices in the nineteenth century demanded precise anatomical knowledge that textbooks and wax models could not provide. Leading surgeons insisted that students perform hands-on dissections to master vascular systems, organ placement, and amputation techniques. Without practical dissection experience, medical graduates risked fatal errors during live surgical procedures.

Under the Murder Act 1752, judges sentenced convicted murderers to public dissection as a posthumous punishment intended to deter violent crime. In Scotland, authorities executed an average of only three to five criminals per year during the 1820s. Consequently, legitimate anatomical theaters faced chronic shortages while student enrollment surged.

To bridge this gap, professional grave robbers known as resurrectionists excavated freshly buried corpses from churchyards under the cover of darkness. Anatomists paid between eight and fourteen pounds per body, depending on the season and physical condition of the corpse. Because English and Scottish common law classified a dead body as nobody’s property, grave robbery constituted only a minor misdemeanor rather than a felony.

Who Was Dr. Robert Knox and What Was His Role?

Credit: google maps

Dr. Robert Knox was a prominent Scottish anatomist and lecturer at Surgeons’ Square in Edinburgh who purchased all sixteen corpses from Burke and Hare. Knox maintained a strict policy of never asking questions about how his anatomical specimens were acquired.

Robert Knox earned his medical degree from the University of Edinburgh in 1814 and studied comparative anatomy in Paris under Georges Cuvier. By 1825, Knox took over Barclay’s Anatomy School at Surgeons’ Square, attracting over four hundred students per term through his engaging lectures and precise dissections. His high student volume required a constant, reliable supply of fresh cadavers throughout the academic winter session.

When Burke and Hare delivered their first corpse in November 1827, Knox’s assistants paid them promptly and encouraged them to return with more subjects. Over the next eleven months, Knox paid between eight and ten pounds for each of the sixteen bodies delivered to his cellar. Even when victims arrived without signs of decomposition or soil from a grave, Knox and his assistants ignored the absence of burial evidence.

Two victims, Mary Paterson and James Wilson, were well-known local figures in Edinburgh whose fresh, unburied bodies raised immediate suspicions among Knox’s students. Despite recognizing James Wilson, a disabled street entertainer known as Daft Jamie, Knox dismissed student inquiries and quickly dissected the corpse to obscure its identity. Although never criminally charged, Knox suffered permanent professional ruin once the public learned of his involvement.

How Were Burke and Hare Caught and Prosecuted?

Burke and Hare were caught on November 1, 1828, after lodgers discovered the strangled body of Margaret Docherty hidden under straw in Burke’s apartment. Following police arrests, William Hare turned King’s Evidence, securing immunity in exchange for testifying against William Burke.

On October 31, 1828, William Burke lured an Irish woman named Margaret Docherty into Tanner’s Close by claiming they shared maternal ancestry. After drinking together, Burke and Hare suffocated Docherty while other lodgers, James and Ann Gray, were temporarily sent away from the premises. Returning the next morning, Ann Gray discovered Docherty’s naked corpse concealed beneath straw at the foot of a bed.

The Grays immediately alerted the Edinburgh police, who arrested Burke, McDougal, Hare, and Logue on November 2, 1828. Because the victims were suffocated without leaving external trauma, forensic pathologists struggled to prove homicide across the fifteen earlier missing persons. Lord Advocate Sir William Rae determined that securing a conviction required insider testimony.

Rae offered William Hare and Margaret Logue full immunity from prosecution if Hare testified against Burke in court. During the twenty-four-hour trial at the High Court of Justiciary in December 1828, Hare detailed the murders of three victims, including Docherty. The jury found William Burke guilty of murdering Margaret Docherty, while finding the case against Helen McDougal not proven.

What Happened After the Trial of William Burke?

William Burke was publicly hanged on January 28, 1829, before a crowd of twenty-five thousand spectators in Edinburgh. Following his execution, Burke’s body was publicly dissected at the University of Edinburgh, and his skeleton remains on permanent display today.

On the morning of January 28, 1829, authorities erected a scaffold in Edinburgh’s Lawnmarket to execute William Burke. Over twenty-five thousand citizens filled the streets, chanting demands for the execution of William Hare and Dr. Robert Knox alongside Burke. Following the hanging, officials transported Burke’s corpse to Professor Alexander Monro’s anatomical theater at the University of Edinburgh.

The next day, Monro performed a public dissection of Burke’s brain before medical students and local dignitaries, dipping a quill pen into Burke’s blood to record the event. Thousands of Edinburgh residents lined up to view the dissected corpse over the following days, mirroring the exact fate Burke had inflicted upon his sixteen victims. Artisans even tanned strips of Burke’s skin to bind pocketbooks sold as morbid souvenirs.

Meanwhile, authorities released William Hare from prison in February 1829, and he fled across the border into England to escape mob violence. Helen McDougal and Margaret Logue also fled Scotland after surviving angry crowds in Edinburgh and Glasgow. Dr. Robert Knox retreated to London, where his medical career collapsed, leaving him to work as a minor lecturer and hospital physician until his death in 1862.

How Did the Anatomy Act 1832 Reform Medical Science?

The Anatomy Act 1832 ended illegal body snatching by granting licensed physicians and medical schools legal access to unclaimed corpses from workhouses and hospitals. This British legislation established transparent regulatory oversight, inspection protocols, and ethical standards for anatomical dissection.

Public outrage over the Burke and Hare murders, combined with the 1831 London Burkers trial of John Bishop and Thomas Williams, forced Parliament to address the cadaver shortage. Introduced by Henry Warburton and championed by philosopher Jeremy Bentham, the Anatomy Act received royal assent on August 1, 1832. The law repealed the provision of the Murder Act 1752 that required the dissection of executed criminals.

Under the new legislation, executors or lawful custodians of deceased individuals could donate unclaimed bodies to licensed anatomy schools unless the deceased had objected in writing before death. Workhouses, prisons, and charitable hospitals became the primary legal suppliers of cadavers for medical education. The act also required all anatomists to obtain government licenses and submit to regular inspections by appointed Inspectors of Anatomy.

Within five years of the act’s implementation, grave robbing and murder-for-dissection vanished across Great Britain. Medical schools gained a steady, legal supply of cadavers, allowing surgeons to advance diagnostic precision, surgical anesthesia techniques, and pathological research. Furthermore, the Anatomy Act 1832 established the legal framework for modern informed body donation programs worldwide.

  1. Why didn’t Dr. Robert Knox go to prison for buying bodies from Burke and Hare?

    Prosecutors found no direct evidence proving Robert Knox knew the corpses were murdered rather than dug up from graves. Because purchasing exhumed cadavers was not a felony under Scottish law in 1828, Knox escaped criminal charges, though public outrage completely destroyed his medical career.

  2. What happened to William Hare after he testified against William Burke?

    William Hare received full legal immunity in exchange for his testimony and was released from jail in February 1829. After surviving violent mobs in Dumfries, Hare escaped across the border into England, where he disappeared from historical records and lived out his life in obscurity.

  3. What is the difference between burking and grave robbing?

    Grave robbing involved digging up recently buried corpses from cemeteries to sell to medical schools, which was a minor misdemeanor. Burking referred specifically to murdering living victims via chest compression and suffocation to sell their fresh, unburied bodies for higher prices.

  4. Is William Burke’s skeleton still on display in Edinburgh?

    Yes, William Burke’s skeleton remains on permanent public display at the Anatomical Museum of the University of Edinburgh. Following his execution and public dissection in January 1829, university officials preserved his bones, death mask, and a pocketbook bound in his tanned skin.

  5. How many people did Burke and Hare actually kill?

    William Burke confessed to murdering sixteen victims between November 1827 and October 1828 in Edinburgh’s West Port district. Sixteen is the exact verified count from Burke’s official prison confession, though rumors at the time falsely claimed the pair killed up to thirty people.

What Are the Best Quiet Alternatives to Arthur’s Seat?
Best Times of Day to Photograph Classic Edinburgh Site Guide
Where to Stay in Edinburgh: Old Town, New Town & More
When Does Edinburgh Christmas Market Start?
When Was Edinburgh Castle Built? History & Timeline 
News Desk
ByNews Desk
Follow:
Independent voice of Edinburgh, delivering timely news, local insights, politics, business, and community stories with accuracy and impact.
Previous Article Dept Q Crew Member Dies After Injury at Edinburgh Studio 2026
Next Article How Did the History of Printing and Publishing in Edinburgh Shape Literature?

All the day’s headlines and highlights from Edinburgh Daily News (EDN), direct to you every morning.

Area We Cover

  • Balerno News
  • Bruntsfield News
  • Calton Hill News
  • Colinton News
  • Corstorphine News
  • Currie News
  • Dean Village News

Explore News

  • Crime News
  • Stabbing News
  • Fire News
  • Live Traffic & Travel News
  • Police News
  • Sports News

Discover EDN

  • About Edinburgh Daily News (EDN)
  • Become EDN Reporter
  • Contact Us
  • Street Journalism Training Programme (Online Course)

Useful Links

  • Contact Us
  • Cookies Policy
  • Code of Ethics
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap

Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) is the part of Times Intelligence Media Group. Visit timesintelligence.com website to get to know the full list of our news publications

Edinburgh Daily News (EDN) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?